SECTION 2

THE PROPERTIES OF HEAVEN
Heaven is supernatural and eternal, and has various degrees of happiness for the Blessed, cor- responding to the higher or lower measure of grace with which each is endowed and the in- timacy of his union with God. 1
i. Eternity of Heaven. — The eternity of Heaven was in olden times denied by the Origen- ists. Benedict XII defined it as an article of faith : "This same vision and fruition . . . continues and will continue till the final judgment, and thenceforward forever." 2 The dogma is as old as Christianity, for the Apostles' Creed says : "I believe ... in life everlasting."
a) Sacred Scripture employs many beautiful figures to illustrate the perpetuity of Heaven. Thus it compares Heaven to "a treasure which faileth not," which "no thief approacheth, nor moth corrupteth;" 3 a reception "into everlast-
l On the supernatural character nuabitur usque ad finale iudicium,
of the beatific vision tee Pohle- et tunc usque in sempiternum."
Preuss, God: His Knowability, Es- (Denzinger-Bannwart, n. 531). sine*, and Attributes, pp. 80 *qq. 8 Luke XII, 33: • . thesaurum
aCfr. the Bull " Benedict us," non deficientem in cat lis: quo fur
A. D. 13 36: " Badem vino et fru- non appropriat, neque tinea corrum*
\Ho . . . continuota esisiU et conti- pit/'
39
Digitized by
THE LAST THINGS OF MAN
ing dwellings 4 "a never fading crown of glory;" 6 an "everlasting kingdom." 6 St. John frequently refers to the abode of the Blessed as "eternal life." 7
b) The Fathers conceived Heaven as unending. Heaven must be everlasting, says St. Augustine, because no happiness could be perfect that would be overshadowed by the fear of a possible cessa- tion or loss. 8 St. Thomas defines eternity as an intrinsic and essential quality without which Heaven would not be Heaven. The opinion of some of the later Scotists that eternity is an acci- dental quality of beatitude, is untenable.
2. Various Degrees of Happiness Among the Blessed. — The ancient heretic Jovinian held that virtues and vices, merits and demerits, re- wards and punishments are all alike. Luther, in accordance with his false theory of justification, contended that glory as well as grace are abso- lutely equal in all men and do not admit of degrees. The Catholic Church, on the contrary, holds as an article of faith that there are among the Blessed various degrees of happiness, in propor-
4 Luke XVI, 9: " Facite vobis 7 Vita aeterna, ^ ctfwvtoy. amicos de mammona iniquitatis: ut, 8 De Civ. Dei, XII, 20: "Quid
quum defeceritis, recipiant vos in enim Hid beatitudine falsius atque
aeterna tabernacuta." fallacius, ubi nos futuros tniseros aut
8 x Pet. V, 4: " Quum apparu- in tantd veritatis luce nesdamus aut
erit princeps pastorum, percipietis in sutntnd f elicit at is arce timeamusf
immorcescibilem gloriae coronam." . . . Atque ita spes nostrae infelicita-
6 a Pet I, xx : " aetemum regnum tit est felix et felicitatis infelix." DomW
Digitized by
HEAVEN
4i
tion to merit. "One is more perfect than the other according to the different merits of each," says e. g. the Decretum Unionis of Florence.*
a) This teaching agrees perfectly with Sacred Scripture. Our Lord Himself intimates that there are various degrees of happiness among the Elect, when He says: "In my Father's house there are many mansions." 10 St. Paul ex- pressly declares : "Each shall receive his own re- ward according to his own toil." 11 And: "He who soweth sparingly, shall also reap sparingly, and he who soweth in blessings, shall also reap blessings." 12 And again: "The glory of the heavenly is different from that of the earthly. There is the glory of the sun, and the glory of the moon, and the glory of the stars; for star dif- fereth from star in glory. And so it is with the resurrection of the dead." 13
The Fathers express themselves in similar terms. St. Polycarp bravely assures his heathen judge : " The more I suffer, the greater will be my reward." 14 St. Ignatius
9". . . pro meritorum tamen di- vet sit ate alium alio psrfsctius." (Detmnger-Bannwart, n. 693).
10 John XIV, 2: "In domo Pa- iris msi mansiones multae sunt."
11 1 Cor. Ill, 8: " Unusquisqus autetn propriam mercedem accipiet secundum suum lab or em.*'
12a Cor. IX, 6: "Qui pares seminat, pares st metet: st qui semi- uat in bsnsdictionibus, ds bsnedic- Honibus si mstst*"
18 1 Cor. XV, 41 sq.: "Alia claritas solis, alia claritas lunae, st alia claritas stellarum. Stella snim a Stella differt in claritate: sic st rssurrsctio mortuorum." — Cfr. AI. Schafcr, Erkldrung der beiden Brief e an die Korinther, pp. 22% aqq., Minister 1903; J. MacRory, The Epistles of St. Paul to ths Corin- thians, P. I, pp. 345 iq., Dublin 1915.
UMartyrium 5. Polyeorpi, 4*
Digitized by
42 THE LAST THINGS OF MAN
of Antioch writes: "The greater the toil, the greater the gain." 15 Tertullian says : " How is it that there are many mansions in the Father's house, if not for the va- riety of merits? How does star differ from star in glory, if not for the diversity of rays ? " 16 St. Jerome argues against Jovinian : " If there is no difference in merits, if virgins do not differ from married women, if the easier works of piety are equally meritorious with the constancy of the martyrs, it is vain to strive for perfection," and proceeds to show how absurd it is to suppose that a death-bed repentance puts the life-long sinner on a level with the Apostles. 17
The objection that inequality of glory in Heaven would provoke envy and jealousy among the Blessed, is re- futed by St. Augustine as follows : " There will be no envy on account of unequal glory, because one love will govern all." 18 According to St. Thomas the measure of glory enjoyed by each is gauged by the strength of the love he has for God: "That intellect which has more of the light of glory will see God the more perfectly ; and he will have a fuller participation of the light of glory who has more of charity, because where there is greater charity, there is a more ardent desire ; . . . hence he who possesses the greater charity, will see God the more per- fectly." 19
15 Ad Polycarp., I, 3: 6vov itXcIojp k6wos, iro\ii icipdos.
itScorpiace, 6: " Quo mo do mul- tae mansiones apud Pattern, si non pro varietate merit orumf Quomodo et stella a stella distabit in gloria, nisi pro diver sit ate radi orumf "
17 Contra Iovin., II, 34: "Si. nulla meritorum diver sit as, si nihil distet inter virgines et tnulieres coniugatas, si aequalis meriti sint leviora virtutum opera et martyrum eonstantia, vanum erit perfections
studium, taediosus omnino erit vir- tutum tabor, omnes a perfectione re- trahentur. Quid per sever ant vir- ginest Quid laborant viduaef Cur maritatae se continent? Peccemus omnes, et post poenitentiam idem erimus quod Apostoli junf."
18 Tract, in Ioa., 67, 3 : " Non erit aliqua invidia imparis claritatis, quoniam regnabit in omnibus unitas caritatis."
19 Summa Theol., ia, qu. 12 1 art 6: "Intellects plus participant d$
Digitized by
HEAVEN
43
b) The inequality of heavenly glory has given rise to the Scholastic doctrine of aureolae, i. e. special marks of success attaching to those who have won conspicuous victories over the three arch-enemies of man, the world, the flesh, and the devil. 20
The aureola of the virgin marks a heroic victory over the flesh; 21 that of the martyr, over the world; 21 that of the doctor, over the devil, who is the father of lies. 28
These marks must be something real, immanent in the soul, and may be conceived as an internal joy over the victory won. What some theologians say of the external visibility of these crowns of glory, or their color, is pure conjecture.
Readings : — *Lessius, De Sutnmo Bono et Aetema Beatitudine Hominis, Antwerp 1616 (ed. Hurter, 1869).— Suarez, De Fine Ultimo. — *Bellarmine, De Sanctorum Beatitudine.— Schnutgen, Vie Visio Beatifica, Wurzburg 1867. — A Krawutzcky, De Visione Beatifica Comment. Histor., Breslau 1868. — Kirschkamp, Gnade und Glorie in ihrem inneren Zusammenhang, Wurzburg 1878.— ♦Bautz, Der Himmel, spekulativ dargestellt, Mayence 1881.-— ♦Franzelin, De Deo Uno, thes. 14-19, Rome 1888. — F. Boudreaux, S.J., Die Seligkeit des Himmels, Kevelaer 1898. — Scheeben, Die Mysterien des Christentums, 3rd ed., pp. 583 sqq., Freiburg 1912. — R Meric, Les £lus se reconnaitront au Ciel, Paris 1881.-— Blot, SJ., Das Wiedererkennen im Jenseits, 10th ed., Mayence
lumine gloriae perfectius Deum vide- bit. Plus autem participabit de lu- mine gloriae. qui plus habet de cart- tate, quia ubi est tnaior caritas, ibi est mains desiderium. . . . Unde qui plus habebit de caritate. perfectius Deum videbit."
20 Cfr. St. Thomas, Summa TheoL, Supplement., qu. 95, art. x : " Au-
reola est aliquid aureae [beatitudini essentiali] superadditum, %. e. quod- dam gaudium de operibus a se factis, quae habent rationem victoriae ex- cellentis."
2iApoc. XIV, 3.
22 Cfr. Matth. V, 11 aq.
28 Cfr. Dan. XII, 3.
Digitized by
44 THE LAST THINGS OF MAN
1900.— G. Gietmann, S.J., art. "Nimbus," in Vol. XI of the Catholic Encyclopedia. — Jos. Hontheim, S.J., art "Heaven," ibid,, Vol. VII.
Digitized by